19 August 2004
:: Ask Dr Tree™ - Muscle/Fat Myths Part I ::

Disclaimer: I'm not a real doctor nor do I have a medical background. Nothing in this entry should be construed as medical advice, it's just my own research and experience. All care but no responsibility taken. Objects in the mirror may be closer than they appear. Lather, rinse, repeat.

I was going to post a rant about all the people who believe that muscle weighs more than fat and that muscle can magically transmogrify into fat and that lifting weights makes you look unfeminine. About how I hate the propagation of ignorance and the idea that this discourages women from doing weight work to help them lose weight.

Instead, Dr Tree™ will explain all.

First of all, muscle DOES NOT weigh more than fat.

Repeat after me: muscle does not weigh more than fat.

Just to be sure I'm clear, muscle does not weigh more than fat.

Muscle is DENSER than fat. What's the difference? Pay attention, this is important, I may test you on it later. It doesn't weigh more. A kilo of muscle weighs exactly the same as a kilo of fat. But the kilo of muscle will be smaller than the kilo of fat. It will take up less space.

If you think about a kilo of lead and a kilo of feathers, they both weigh the same, but the pile of feathers will be much bigger than the lead. It's the same with muscle and fat.

Poor Kim discovered this the hard way just recently. While her weight had not changed on the scales, all of a sudden her clothes fit better. This puzzled her.

If she had gained a pound of muscle and lost a pound of fat, then this makes perfect sense. Her weight would be unchanged, but she would be physically smaller.

Another example: You get two women, both who weigh 70kg. One trains with weights, the other does little or no exercise. The weight lifter will be smaller than the other girl. She will wear a smaller clothing size. Why? Because she has a lower body fat percentage than the other girl. She has a higher muscle mass percentage. So while she weighs the same as the other girl, her muscle takes up less room than the fat on the other girl.

So, the lesson to learn here? Putting on muscle is good for you. While the needle on the scale might not go down, the size of your jeans certainly will. Besides, muscle burns fat even when you're asleep. It needs to burn fat just to maintain itself. How can something that burns fat while you sleep be bad?

Look forward to future rants in the Ask Dr Tree™ series: 'No, you're not going to turn into Arnold Schwarzenegger if you lift weights', 'If you think muscle turns into fat or vice versa, I have a lovely bridge to sell you' and 'What do you mean you don't measure yourself as well as weigh yourself, are you out of your mind?'


ladymisstree | 09:46 PM | Take a bite (9)

Brava! Already looking forward to the next installment. :-)


Served up by Beth S. at 11:28 on 19|08|04


Love it. hope u don;t mind I popped a linkto this entry in my journal. It is so true!!!! :)


Served up by Angel at 12:01 on 20|08|04


You sure got that one right, mistree! I havent lost a pound in a month but i am losing inches which is a big consolation! It also goes to show you don't base your success solely on what the scale says.


Served up by LibrarianOnTheLoose at 06:44 on 20|08|04


How 'bout when you don't lose pounds OR inches (leastways not in the places you're measuring) but you ARE fitting into smaller clothes? That's one mystery I can't work out. Is it just bravado/ wishful thinking ("I WILL squeeze into these jeans")? heh.


Served up by Kimba at 08:34 on 20|08|04


Thanks for the link, first off. :)

Secondly, I fully understand the concept that you have so adeptly explained. The reason I still feel puzzled about what's going on with my body... is that I haven't been doing any weights. And cardio only 2-3 times a week. (Some weeks in July, none.) That's why it made no sense to me.

Instead of trying to figure it out, I went on a few-day binge and now that loose-clothing for no reaso problem? Not as much of a problem. ;)

But thanks, and I am enjoying your site.


Served up by Kim at 04:04 on 21|08|04


Oh, and another thing! The woman who lifts weights is going to decrease her percentage of body fat much more than the woman who does hours and hours of cardio. The cardio woman might burn more calories per workout, but she's not building muscle and not raising her metabolism. I like to think of this as a hare/tortoise thing--the weight-lifter is the tortoise, and she's going to be much heathier in the long run.


Served up by Beth S. at 03:25 on 22|08|04


THANK YOU for spelling this out for us. Honestly, the more I hear people say that muscle weighs more than fat, the more I want to beat myself in the head with a frying pan. A pound is a pound is a pound. Thank you for wording it in a way that (hopefully) most people will understand!


Served up by Melanie at 03:00 on 23|08|04


Yes indeed. Not only that, but I've found that even after you stop losing weight, you keep losing inches. I bought new clothes when I hit my goal, and am now finding that even THOSE are too loose on me!


Served up by Bill^2 at 12:31 on 24|08|04


"Which weighs more, a pound of bricks or a pound of feathers?" ONE brick weighs more than ONE feather. Imagine one fat molecule to one muscle molecule, not in terms of kilograms, which is a weight measurement. Chew on that for a bit, baby.


Served up by Julie at 04:04 on 20|11|04