27 August 2004
:: Ask Dr Tree™ - Scales: Evil Lurks In Your Bathroom ::

Disclaimer: I'm not a real doctor nor do I have a medical background. Nothing in this entry should be construed as medical advice, it's just my own research and experience. All care but no responsibility taken. Not valid in all states. Do not exceed recommended dosage. Void if removed.

I posted recently about the way we all crave external validation. We live and die by a list of numbers; kilograms, pounds, inches, centimeters, clothing sizes, whatever.

It is not enough that we feel healthier, that we can walk without puffing, that we sleep better, that we have more energy. We need those numbers to make us feel like we’re doing the right thing.

And there is no number more insidious than that on the dial of a set of scales.

We measure because it’s a simple way to quantify our achievement. But that only makes sense in a stable environment.

The female body is NOT a stable environment.

There is stuff going on in there constantly. Things are changing on a daily, hourly basis. Processes that are necessary for us to survive, processes that can create such profound change in such a short period of time that a static measuring tool like a scale simply can't keep up. Certainly not on a daily basis, anyway.

Unfortunately, that is how a lot of us use scales.

You always hear people telling you not to weigh yourself every day. You've probably wondered why. Let Dr Tree™ explain it all.

The inimitable JuJu at The Skinny Daily wrote about this very phenomenon recently; Overnight Gains. By the way, if you’re not already reading The Skinny regularly, what's wrong with you? Go on, go read. I'll still be here when you get back.

She outlines a whole raft of reasons why your humble bathroom scales just can't cope with daily weigh-ins. Your body is doing so many crazy things on a daily basis that your poor scales can't possibly keep up. Take water retention. No, please, really, take it, for the love of all that's holy…

Not only that, but your scales are only giving you a tiny piece of the weight loss puzzle. We've already covered why your weight might not change but your body might shrink. The scales can only give you a reading of your current mass, it can't tell you WHY you weigh what you do.

So, of course, if the number on the scale isn't in your favour, you freak out. But I ate really well, I did all my exercise, I did all the right things, WHY GOD WHY?!

And then you go and eat your body weight in chocolate mud cake.

Or you get on the scales and the number makes you smile but last week you ate lard burgers with a side serving of lard and glued your butt to the sofa. So you eat an entire chocolate mud cake in celebration because the scales let you think you can get away with it.

We need to keep what the scales tell us in perspective. It's only one part of the total weight loss process and it is an uninformed part of that process. It's not the be all and end all.

Your bathroom scales are a tool. Understand that and understand their limitations.

Don't let them dictate how you feel about what you've achieved.

This has been another quality rant by Dr Tree™ - Making nutritional and fitness mistakes for 20 years so you don't have to.


ladymisstree | 12:42 AM | Take a bite (3)

You're my hero, did you know that?

I started on the scale just to give myself an idea of what was happening. A jumping off point. I needed to know where I was starting... and, realistically... how bad it had gotten. It was worse than I thought, and that's a good thing -- if it wasn't as bad, I may not have worked so hard to get it under control.

I have stepped on the scale only once in the past two months -- that one time was simply to get an idea of what was going on with my body, since it did feel much smaller than it had before.

But I do understand the whole concept of weight being dynamic -- I was just puzzled as all hell about how I could feel SO much smaller (not just a bit, but a lot) yet weigh exactly the same.

In any case, I'm not a slave to my scale anymore... I feel good, and know what I need to do to keep losing. It's just a matter of doing.


Served up by Kim at 03:14 on 27|08|04


I have to say, all the reasons you gave is exactly why I do weigh myself all the time. Sometimes a couple of times a day, sometimes a couple of times a week. The number is always different. But it doesn't get to me at all. I take it as a piece of information, meaningless without lots of other pieces of information. I have always felt that if I only weigh myself once a week, what happens if that moment is one when the scale is high? If that is my only piece of data for the week, I will believe it as evidence of my (lack of) progress. If, on the other hand I just weighed myself the day before, I can see that the number is an abberation. For example, my weight these days is about 175. Some days it is 175.5 or 176 or even 174.5. The other day it said 179. But guess what? In the morning, just a few hours later, it said 175.5. What if I hadn't weighed in again? I would have believed that I had gained 4 pounds!! But I just laughed because I knew there was no way that was an accurate number. I find frequent weigh-ins grant the very perspective people accuse them of taking away. I recognize that not everyone (in fact, almost no one) feels the same way, and no one should subject themselves to anything that will thwart their efforts. But some folks might take comfort in seeing the fluctuations & be able to take them in stride.


Served up by Karen at 05:06 on 27|08|04


Boy does this all make sense! I've been slacking on exercise but the scale has been dropping. But I don't look much better since I'm not toning up. Weight is so arbitrary. Thanks for the thoughts!


Served up by Cat at 01:09 on 29|08|04